11+ Biggest Difference Between Carnival and Royal Caribbean
Royal Caribbean and Carnival are two of the most popular cruise lines in the world, known for their exciting experiences and massive ships.
Both cater primarily to American cruisers, but each brings its own flavor to the cruising experience.
While they share similarities, there are key differences that set them apart.
We’ll explore some important distinctions that could help you decide which cruise line is the best match for your next getaway.
The Size & Amenities
When it comes to cruise ships, size matters—especially if you’re sailing with Royal Caribbean.
Their Icon Class ships, like the Icon of the Seas and the upcoming Star of the Seas, are the largest cruise ships in the world. These floating cities boast 20 decks, seven pools, a massive water park, and even an ice skating rink.
Whether you’re zip-lining across the ship or enjoying a Broadway-style show, there’s no shortage of activities. Royal Caribbean’s ships are designed to give you a bit of everything, so you’ll never get bored.
Carnival, on the other hand, seems to focus not on ship size but rather on the quality of entertainment on board.
The newer Excel-class ships, like the Mardi Gras, Carnival Celebration, and Carnival Jubilee, strike the perfect balance—neither too small nor too large.
These ships have some awesome attractions, including BOLT, the first roller coaster at sea, which is definitely a standout feature.
Carnival’s focus is all about fun, offering lively pools, water slides, and plenty of entertainment to keep the party going without overwhelming you with ship size. It’s a perfect mix of comfort and excitement!
The Atmosphere
Royal Caribbean offers a more relaxed, family-friendly vibe, especially on its newer ships. While it’s upscale in some areas, it’s designed for families who want to enjoy a comfortable, enjoyable vacation without feeling rushed.
You’ll find plenty of space to relax, whether you’re hanging out at one of the pools or attending a Broadway-style show.
It’s perfect for families, couples, and anyone looking to enjoy a cruise with a little more sophistication, but still full of fun and adventure for all ages.
Carnival, on the other hand, is all about a lively, party-oriented atmosphere. If you love energy and excitement, Carnival is the place to be.
It’s perfect for groups, families with younger kids, or anyone looking for a fun, carefree vacation. From deck parties to fun activities like trivia and karaoke, there’s always something happening on board.
The vibe is casual and fun, so you can let loose and enjoy your time with friends and family, knowing that you’re in the middle of a lively cruise experience!
The Food and Dining Experiences
Royal Caribbean offers a more refined dining experience, with a variety of specialty options that will satisfy even the pickiest eaters.
The buffet is a little more upscale and diverse, and you can also indulge in gourmet dining experiences like Wonderland—a unique, whimsical restaurant offering a one-of-a-kind meal.
Whether you’re in the mood for a casual bite or a fancy dinner, Royal Caribbean has a wide range of dining options that cater to both laid-back meals and more formal experiences, making it ideal for families who want to enjoy quality food in a relaxed but sophisticated setting.
Carnival, on the other hand, is famous for its casual, fun dining options. If you’re craving a burger, you can’t go wrong with Guy’s Burger Joint, or if you’re in the mood for some tasty BBQ, Guy’s BBQ has you covered.
Carnival’s dining experience is laid-back, with a focus on delicious, hearty meals that are perfect for families and casual cruisers.
You won’t find any fancy dress codes or complicated menus here—just good food and a relaxed atmosphere, making it a great choice for those who want to enjoy a fun, no-stress dining experience.
The Entertainment
Royal Caribbean takes entertainment to the next level with high-production shows that will leave you in awe.
You can enjoy Broadway-style musicals, jaw-dropping performances at the Aqua Theater, and innovative venues like the 270° lounge, which offers stunning views and unique entertainment experiences.
Whether you’re watching a spectacular acrobatic show or enjoying a movie under the stars, Royal Caribbean’s entertainment is top-notch and perfect for those looking for a bit of glam and excitement on their cruise.
Carnival’s entertainment, however, is all about fun and energy. If you love comedy, deck parties, and lively events, Carnival is where you’ll want to be.
Their cruise directors are known for being some of the best in the business, keeping the energy high and making sure everyone is having a blast.
Whether it’s a party on the deck or a friendly competition, Carnival’s entertainment is perfect for anyone who loves to let loose and have fun. It’s the ideal choice for cruisers who want a more upbeat and social atmosphere.
The Cost $$$
When it comes to price, Royal Caribbean tends to be more expensive, especially on similar itineraries and ship classes.
While the cost is a bit higher, you’re paying for the luxurious experience and the wide range of amenities and activities onboard.
If you’re looking for a more upscale vacation with a variety of dining options, entertainment, and sophisticated spaces, Royal Caribbean is a great choice.
It’s ideal for those who don’t mind spending a bit more for the added luxury and comfort.
Carnival, on the other hand, offers more affordable options, making it a popular choice for families and younger crowds who want to get the most value for their money.
Carnival’s ships deliver plenty of fun and excitement at a lower price point, so you can still enjoy an action-packed cruise without breaking the bank.
If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option that doesn’t skimp on fun, Carnival has you covered with a great value for families or anyone seeking a more casual, relaxed vacation experience.
The Itineraries and Departure Ports
Royal Caribbean offers longer, more varied itineraries that take you to exciting destinations like Europe, Asia, and Australia.
If you’re looking to explore a wide range of destinations beyond the typical Caribbean spots, Royal Caribbean has you covered.
Whether it’s a multi-week adventure through the Mediterranean or an exotic cruise to the Far East, Royal Caribbean’s itineraries cater to the seasoned traveler who’s eager to see more of the world.
With departures from major ports, you’ll have a wide variety of options to choose from.
Carnival, on the other hand, focuses more on shorter, fun-filled cruises to popular destinations like the Caribbean, Bahamas, and Mexico.
If you’re looking for a quick getaway with less time commitment, Carnival’s itineraries are perfect for you.
Plus, Carnival sails from smaller ports like Mobile, Alabama, and New Orleans, which is great for cruisers who live near those areas or want to avoid long flights.
It’s all about convenience and making your vacation more accessible without the need for major travel before you even board.
The Private Destinations
Royal Caribbean’s private destination, Perfect Day at CocoCay in the Bahamas, is the ultimate vacation spot.
With upgraded amenities like the perfect blend of relaxation and adventure, it’s a place where you can kick back on pristine beaches, float in the crystal-clear waters, or enjoy thrilling activities like water slides and a floating water park.
CocoCay offers the ultimate “vacation vibe,” with plenty of space to unwind while soaking in the tropical sun. If you’re cruising to the Bahamas, it’s the perfect spot to spend a day in paradise.
Carnival’s private islands, while still offering fun beach vibes, don’t quite match the luxury of Royal Caribbean’s CocoCay—at least not until Celebration Key comes online.
Carnival’s private destinations tend to have a more laid-back, relaxed feel, offering you the chance to enjoy a quieter, more chilled beach day.
You won’t find the same level of upscale amenities, but if you’re looking for a simple, no-frills beach experience, Carnival’s islands are perfect for enjoying the sun and surf without the crowds.
The Ships
When it comes to Royal Caribbean’s ships, there’s a clear difference between the older ones and the newer ones.
While some of the older ships might feel a little dated and lack the same charm, the newer ships, like the Oasis-class, are absolutely massive and filled with innovative spaces.
Think Central Park, a beautiful garden area right in the middle of the ship, or the Boardwalk, complete with a carousel and aqua theater. Royal Caribbean’s newer ships are a marvel of design, offering a mix of luxury and adventure that’s hard to beat.
Carnival’s older ships, on the other hand, have a lot more character and personality. They tend to feel cozier and more inviting, with quirky touches that make them feel like home.
Carnival’s newer ships strike a balance between fun and comfort. They’re not as giant as Royal Caribbean’s, but they still pack in some unique attractions, like BOLT, the first roller coaster at sea.
Whether it’s the charm of the older ships or the excitement of the newer ones, Carnival knows how to make each ship feel like an exciting place to explore.
The Service and Crew
Royal Caribbean is known for its polished service and attention to detail, with crew members who go above and beyond to ensure you have a luxurious and comfortable experience.
Whether it’s your stateroom attendant greeting you with a smile or the restaurant staff going the extra mile to make your meal special, the service is refined and top-notch.
If you’re looking for a seamless, elegant experience, Royal Caribbean’s crew is dedicated to making every moment aboard feel like a VIP experience.
Carnival, on the other hand, offers a more friendly and casual service that fits with the laid-back vibe of the cruise.
The crew is warm and approachable, making you feel like part of the family right from the start.
Carnival’s cruise directors, in particular, are known for their high-energy, fun-loving personalities that help set the tone for the entire cruise.
Whether you’re at a deck party or joining a game show, the crew’s energetic and personable approach makes Carnival cruises feel lively and fun from start to finish.
The Cruise Lengths and Flexibility
Royal Caribbean offers more options for long cruises, making it ideal for travelers who want to explore multiple destinations over an extended period.
Although they have been shifting a little to shorter cruises for their older ships, they are known for longer getaways.
Whether it’s a two-week European adventure or an extended Caribbean getaway, Royal Caribbean gives you plenty of flexibility with its longer itineraries.
This is perfect for seasoned cruisers or anyone looking for an immersive vacation experience that lets you dive deeper into a variety of destinations.
If you have the time and want a more in-depth cruise experience, Royal Caribbean has you covered.
Carnival specializes in short, quick getaways, making it the perfect choice for those who want to escape for a few days without the long commitment.
Their cruises typically range from 3 to 7 days, offering a fun, relaxing experience without taking up too much of your time.
If you’re looking for a quick vacation to recharge or want to squeeze in a getaway without taking weeks off work, Carnival’s short itineraries are ideal.
It’s all about enjoying the cruise without the need for a lengthy time commitment.
The Loyalty Programs
Royal Caribbean’s Crown & Anchor Society offers some seriously comprehensive rewards, especially if you’re cruising frequently and hitting higher tiers.
Members can enjoy perks like access to exclusive lounges, priority boarding, and complimentary dining options, making it a great program for loyal cruisers who want to enjoy extra luxury.
The higher the tier, the more exclusive the benefits, including access to special events and even free upgrades. If you’re a frequent Royal Caribbean cruiser, the Crown & Anchor Society rewards you in a big way.
Carnival’s Very Important Fun Person (VIFP) program, while not as elaborate, is perfect for cruisers who appreciate the practical perks.
It’s all about making your vacation easier and more enjoyable with benefits like priority boarding and complimentary laundry services.
If you’re looking for simple rewards that make your cruise experience more convenient without needing to climb through tiers, the VIFP program has you covered.
It’s a no-fuss option that’s perfect for those who just want a little extra convenience during their cruise.
TL;DR
Royal Caribbean and Carnival are both popular cruise lines, but they offer different experiences.
Royal Caribbean is known for its large, luxurious ships with upscale amenities, ideal for families seeking a relaxed, refined vacation.
It offers longer itineraries to destinations like Europe and Asia and features high-end entertainment.
On the other hand, Carnival is known for its fun, lively atmosphere, with affordable short getaways and more casual dining and entertainment.
It’s perfect for groups or younger travelers looking for a more energetic, laid-back vibe. Whether you prefer a luxurious experience or a budget-friendly, fun cruise, each line offers something unique for your next getaway.
